The Old Guard 2 follows Andy once again leading her group of immortal warriors against a powerful new enemy with the fate of their secretive group at stake. This time, their mission became even more complicated by the return of a long-lost immortal, adding tension and intrigue to the story.
While the film introduced several new diverse characters, I felt the development for these additions was lacking; their backstories and motivations never quite came into focus. The action, a hallmark of the series, didn’t stand out as much this time around, with several sequences feeling repetitive. One particular battle scene felt like it had been lifted straight from Dune, lacking the original energy that made the first film so fun to watch.
There was an interesting plot twist toward the end, offering at least some fresh narrative energy. However, the script often veered into corny territory with lines that felt painfully written and unconvincing. Visually, though, the movie delivered: it was clear that substantial resources had been spent on both the cinematography and the costuming.
I was hoping for a conclusive ending, but instead the film opted to tee up yet another sequel, leaving major plot lines unresolved. Although The Old Guard films are loosely based on the acclaimed graphic novels, this installment, like the last, just didn’t translate the source material’s depth or excitement.
Looking back, I should have listened to my instinct after the first movie. Despite the visual appeal, The Old Guard 2 ultimately falls flat, relying too heavily on familiar formulas and leaving its most interesting ideas underdeveloped.