Emilia Pérez is a Spanish musical crime drama directed by French filmmaker Jacques Audiard, starring Zoe Saldaña, Karla Sofía Gascón and Selena Gomez. The story centers on Manitas Del Monte, a formidable Mexican drug cartel leader who fakes his death to undergo gender-affirming surgery.
The film's attempt to blend melodrama, musical theater, and social commentary resulted in a tonally inconsistent experience. The musical numbers felt uninspired and poorly integrated, with noticeable vocal struggles and awkward transitions from dialogue to song. While the plot offered moments of unpredictability, it lacked substantial depth, and the superficial exploration of serious issues like Mexico’s disappeared victims undermined their potential impact. Additionally, the depiction of gender-affirming surgery lacked the necessary sensitivity and nuance, understandably drawing criticism from LGBTQ+ communities
Cultural misrepresentation was another significant flaw; despite being set in Mexico, the main cast is not predominantly Mexican. Native Spanish speakers also criticized the dialogue saying it was disconnected from its cultural context. Audiard’s lack of direct ties to Mexico exacerbated this issue, which resulted in a perspective that lacked an authentic portrayal.
Zoe Saldaña and Karla Sofía Gascón delivered commendable performances, bringing emotional depth to their roles despite the script's limited character development. Saldaña, portrayal of Rita, a lawyer entangled in Emilia's transformation, offered a grounded intensity that added complexity to the narrative. Gascón's portrayal of Emilia captured the internal conflict of a character seeking redemption while haunted by past transgressions.
Despite the off-screen controversies that plagued its awards season, Emilia Pérez, ultimately faltered due to its own cinematic shortcomings. The musical numbers detracted from the overall experience, and its handling of sensitive topics like gender identity and Mexico’s social issues felt superficial. Though celebrated at Cannes and recognized with numerous awards, including Oscars for Best Supporting Actress (Saldaña) and Best Original Song ("El Mal"), Emilia Pérez fell short of being a truly Oscar-worthy film in my opinion. Despite its ambitious premise, the film's execution was inconsistent, leaving much to be desired.