Train Dreams

 

Train Dreams is a sprawling, meditative period drama that feels like a quiet, yet heavy, transition from the old world into the new. Directed by Clint Bentley and based on the Denis Johnson novella, the film follows Robert Grainier, played by Joel Edgerton, as he navigates a life of labor and loss in the turn-of-the-century Pacific Northwest.

While the slow-paced narrative could easily be interpreted as boring by some, the sheer scale of the cinematography created a profound sense of isolation, making you feel lonely even when characters are on screen.

The writing was incredibly strong, particularly in the heartbreaking scenes between Robert and Claire, played brilliantly by Kerry Condon, which actually moved me to tears. The chemistry between Edgerton and Felicity Jones, who played Gladys, was also so palpable it made you truly root for them. While, I wasn’t a huge fan of the choice to include narration from Will Patton, I suppose it fit the era’s oral storytelling tradition.

I deeply appreciated the film’s commitment to historical honesty and diversity. It took a hard look at the Chinese Exclusion Act, showing the systemic mistreatment faced by Chinese railroad workers. Beyond that, the inclusion of Indigenous actors like Nathaniel Arcand, who played Robert's friend and storekeeper, Ignatius Jack, added a layer of authenticity to the setting that many period pieces miss.

Even though I wouldn't have personally voted for Train Dreams to be nominated for Best Picture, I can still appreciate the strong writing and inclusive casting that will make it a significant piece of cinema.